Sharon ([info]azriona) wrote,
@ 2008-12-30 06:48:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:children of time, doctor who, talking about fanfiction

Children of Time Awards, Round One Aftermath
As you know, the Children of Time awards have finished their voting, and posted their winners. And, as it turns out, the pages listing the nominees have been removed from the site - which among other things, makes it difficult to continue reviewing the ones I didn't get to review previously.

But, it also seems that the new round of nominations will begin on 1 January, and go through the end of the month, so perhaps this is just as well. There are just over 100 categories, all told (although not all are DW - some are Torchwood, or Sarah Jane Adventures), and even with each category capped at 15 fics apiece, that's quite a few new fics for me to review.

I cannot get them all in a month. Nor will I try. But I will try to review a decent percentage of them, and with luck, introduce you to stories you wouldn't have read otherwise. Which, after all, is the point.

However, for now - let's look at the winners of round one.

There were fifteen Doctor Who categories in which to vote - of these fifteen, six of the stories I voted for won or received Runner-Up in the categories for which I voted them. (A seventh story won a separate category, but at least it won!)

(And before you ask - no, I did not vote for Crossroads. Good lord, people, there were too many good fics on that list - I doubt the person who nominated Crossroads voted for Crossroads, in the end.)

But more importantly, there were at least six fics for which I voted, and did not win anything, and should have. I'm going to list them here, because I do think they deserved the win - and as the rules allow for nominees to be nominated again, I believe they should go up again.

So, in no particular order:

Six Stages by [info]gowdie, reviewed in Part One.
Now, Gowdie did win the title of Best New Author - which makes it doubly ironic that her fic didn't get so much as a nod when it came to the final standings. Moreover, Gowdie's written several other pieces since Six Stages was posted, and all of them have shown the same joy and humor as her first. Yes, she totally deserved the Best New Author nod. However, I'd like to see one of her fics hit the big time, and Six Stages is definitely of the best, and deserves a nod of its own.

The Loved 'verse by [info]fid_gin, with appearances by [info]unfolded73, reviewed in Part Twelve.
There is quite simply no other Ten/TenII/Rose fic quite like this out there. It's a delight to read, from start to finish, and has so many lovely possibilities going on within it. TenII is working out to be an absolutely fascinating interpretation of the Doctor as a human, and the interactions between he and his crew mates are splendid.

Not One Line by rickmaniac101, reviewed in Part One.
Yes, it's River Song. Yes, it's River/Doctor, and we all know I have a weakness for that. But this truly is a fantastic work, mapping out River's life with and without the Doctor, and by the end, you feel for River, far more deeply than you might have expected. You might not like River, but you'll understand her. This fic deserves more attention that it received.

Ulysses by [info]rheanna27, reviewed in Part Seven.
It's a twisty, turny, time-whimey alternate look at how the end of Human Nature/Family of Blood might have ended. There are a thousand versions of those episodes in fanfic form. This is like none of them. It's fantastic and wonderful and even if you hate Martha (and I'm not a fan), you'll admire her in this.

More Than an Echo by [info]samfeasnor, reviewed in Part Nine.
The best Jenny!fic out there. Period. It's sweet and funny and sad and utterly fantastic. Jenny would make her father proud, and Sam should be proud of what she's done with her. This series of short one-shots hasn't gotten near the attention it deserves.

Cheating Time by [info]wendymr and [info]dark_aegis, reviewed in Part Twelve.
This is the sort of twisty timey-whimey nonsense that has been known to give me headaches. Therefore, pass the aspirin and dive right in. It's a brilliant look at Ten's desperation following Last of the Time Lords, and it's easy to believe that his actions could very well have been canon.



(Post a new comment)


[info]jlrpuck
2008-12-30 02:49 pm UTC (link)
You're insane for attempting to tackle the reviews--and you're fantastic for managing to do so many, so quickly.

Which makes you insanely fantastic for deciding to give it another go in round two. You? Are Made of Awesome.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-30 10:27 pm UTC (link)
*grin* Hmm...insane...and fantastic. I can live with that.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]papilio_luna
2008-12-30 04:48 pm UTC (link)
I'm so with you on Six Stages and the Loved verse (both of which I nommed so hard I almost set my computer on fire). I will most certainly be nomming them both again. I'm glad that [info]gowdie won for new author but I think that [info]fid_gin needs way, way more love. Yeah, she writes a threesome that might squick some folks, but the fact that she does it in a way that makes people who normally aren't in to slash or OT3 go absolutely ga-ga over it deserves an award of its very own. And really I don't know of any other author writing that threesome on any kind of regular basis.

And I can't believe you're going to do all that again! Thanks for the reminder to start getting my noms together!

Edited at 2008-12-30 05:55 pm UTC

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-30 10:26 pm UTC (link)
Yes, please, nom those two again. It means I don't have to. :)

Also, congrats on 9.8 Metres. You go, girl. And if One True Free Life is nommed on the next go-round, it's top of the list for a review from me, you know. Heck, it's near the top of the list after I'm done with my fanfic break (right after [info]jlrpuck's AU Peter/Rose ficlets). :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]dameruth
2008-12-30 05:15 pm UTC (link)
You. Are. Amazing.

Personally, I really hope we get fewer people nominating whole *series* at one shot, unless we're talking drabble-series or some such; otherwise the word count just goes crazy and there's no way to read all the nominees.

FWIW, I heard that the voting was so insanely close, the whole setup of winners and runners-up kept morphing completely every time each new person's votes were counted. I believe it.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-30 10:24 pm UTC (link)
I, for one, am glad she didn't post the numbers - although I'd be curious to know how many people voted overall.

But I'm probably standing alone, there. :)

I do have to point out that "series" isn't listed in the length category. Which is a shame, if you ask me, because there are lots of excellent series out there. Not sure if that's an oversight, or not.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]dameruth
2008-12-30 11:18 pm UTC (link)
Actually, I'm curious about the number of people voting (if not the actual scores received by any of the nominees . . . heh!), too.

As I understand it, removing the "series" category, and allowing series to be nominated anywhere as if they were single stories was a result of so many people nominating fics without checking/understanding if they were actual series, or just multi-chapter fics.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-30 11:33 pm UTC (link)
Ah! So a series could be nominated as Romance, or Dark, or Crack!fic? Okay, I can live with that.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]dameruth
2008-12-30 11:52 pm UTC (link)
*If* I'm understanding it right (and be sure to double-check the actual rules, since my brain is notoriously unreliable), you can nominate series anywhere you can nominate an individual story. They aren't separated at all.

Edited at 2008-12-30 11:52 pm UTC

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]wendymr
2008-12-31 12:29 am UTC (link)
I think you're insane to be willing to review again, but I admire you greatly for it! And I'll be looking forward with interest to your next set of reviews. You're also reminding me that I haven't read enough of the newer Doctor/Rose fics (mostly Ten/Rose); mainly because there've simply been so many, and so many retreading the same ground, that I almost stopped reading that pairing except for a few authors I already knew and trusted. It sounds, from your reviews and the recaps of a couple of them here, as if there are stories I need to be reading when I get a chance - including Pages.

My offer still stands, by the way - I'm not sure if you ever saw my PM, but as a small gesture of appreciation for all your reviews, and especially your very kind words about Cheating Time, [info]dark_aegis and I would be happy to write a fic to a prompt of your choice (with any of the following characters: Nine, Ten, TenII, Rose, Jack, Jackie, Donna). Of course, only if your brain can handle yet more fic!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-31 11:39 am UTC (link)
I think you're insane to be willing to review again

What, only think? I'm definitely insane.

there are stories I need to be reading when I get a chance - including Pages

There are definitely stories, yes.

But you'll get to Pages when you get to it. Or you won't. No worries.

I'm not sure if you ever saw my PM

I did see - apologies for not responding. At the moment, I'm still somewhat winded on fanfic, so I'm trying not to think too hard about it until after the New Year (as in possibly this weekened). But I do appreciate the offer, and I'll take you up on it, once I figure out what I want to see!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]samfeasor
2008-12-31 03:34 am UTC (link)
I know I said thank you before when you initially recommended my series, but I'd just like to repeat and reemphasize my gratitude. I really really appreciate it.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]azriona
2008-12-31 11:39 am UTC (link)
You're welcome! It's really a gorgeous series, more people should see it than have so far.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…